Jacques Mariten's Peripatetic Critique of Modern Philosophers on the Priority of Epistemology over Ontology

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Professor of Tarbiat Modares University

2 Ph.D. in Tarbiat Modares University

10.22061/orj.2021.1583

Abstract

Maritain, as one of the neothomist philosophers, believes in the return to Thomas Aquinas’s views in all philosophical fields. One of the topics of interest to Maritain is modern epistemology, which has not only been isolated from metaphysics but also prioritized and is the first topic raised in the works of Descartes. Maritain argues that this primacy has led to idealism and the perversion of philosophy, since epistemology is one of metaphysical issues and should be raised after metaphysical premises, in particular ontology.
Maritain presents critical realism, which is based on reality and existence as rational truth that expressed in sensory terms, against modern philosophers views. That is to say, the sense and experience of human being is the first encounter with the external world, but that reason dominates all levels of perception and validates human perceptions, intends the existence of the object behind its empirical appearance. The most important comprehension of reason, then, is the existence which beside quiddity forms  basic structure of any object. Accordingly, all modern epistemological views are either realistic or idealistic, but are rejected as idealists, because they ignore the role of external reality or “thing” in shaping mental “object”.

Keywords

References

Aquinas T, On Being and Essence, Translated by Robert T. Miller, In Sancti Thomae de Aquino Opera Omnia, Rome: Commissio Leonina; 1997.
Avani Q, [Translation of A History Of Phylosophy Descartes To Leibnitz]. Copleston F (Author), Tehran: Soroush; 2009. Persian.
Gilson E, Thomism Realism and Critique of Knowledge, Translated by Mark A. Wauck, San Francisco: Ignatius Press; 2012.
Ibn  sina, Alshefa (Elahiyat, Manteq, Tabiyat), Qom: Maktabah Marashi; 1984; (Arabic)
Ilkhani M, History Of Philosophy in the Middle Ages and the Renaissance, sixth edition, Tehran: Samt; 2013. persian.
Kant I, Critique of pure reason, Translated by Paul Guyer,Allen W. Wood, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1998.
Khoramshahi B, [Translation of A History Of Phylosophy Bentham To Russell]. Copleston F (Author), Tehran: Soroush; 2010. Persian.
Knasas J F X Transcendental Tomist Methodology and Maritain’s Critical realism, In Douglas A, Ollivant (Editor), Jacques Maritain and the Many Ways of Knowing, Washington, D.C: The Catholic University of America Press; 2002.
Mahdavi Y, [Translationof A look At Contemporary Phenomenology And Philosophy Of Existence]. Verneaux R (Author), Tehran: Kharazmi; 1993. Persian.
Maritain J, A Preface To Metaphysics, London: Sheed and Ward; 1945.
Maritain J, Existence and Existent, The Modern Classic Philosophy, New York: Paulist Press; 2015.
Maritain J, the Degrees of Knowledge, Notre Dame, Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press; 1995.
Maritain J, the Range of Reason, New York: Scribner; 1952.
Maritain J, Three reformers Luther-Descartes-Rousseau, New York: Charles Scribner’s sons, 1929.
Qavamsafari M, How Is Metaphysics Possible, First edition, Tehran: Research Institute For Islamic Culture And Thought ; 2007. Persian.
Journal of Ontological Researches
Volume 10, Issue 19
September 2021

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics